SEO case study · Life insurance, Australia

Ending the Zurich vs OnePath cannibalization in Australian life insurance

Giving each brand one role in search, then winning consumer research queries with a trust-led hub that routes people to an adviser.

2 brands
competing for the same life insurance queries
Client: Zurich Australia and OnePath (Zurich)
Published November 20, 2026

An SEO engagement from before November 2026, when I focused my practice on AI authority and reputation for wealth management firms. The method (technical foundations, authority, measurement) carries over. What I do now.

Context

Zurich completed its acquisition of ANZ’s life insurance business, OnePath Life, on 3 June 2019, with a 20-year agreement to distribute life insurance through ANZ (Zurich Australia). The price was A$2.85 billion (Zurich Insurance Group). On 1 August 2022, OnePath Life policies transferred to Zurich Australia Limited, and Zurich kept the OnePath brand. Together, the two brands serve more than 2 million customers in Australia (OnePath).

The challenge

  1. Two brands competing for the same queries. zurich.com.au and onepath.com.au both target “income protection insurance”, “TPD insurance” and “trauma cover”. Google ranks one, sometimes the other, sometimes neither.
  2. Adviser and consumer intent mixed up. Most life cover is sold through advisers, but the most searched queries are consumer research: “how much life insurance do I need”, “is income protection tax deductible”. Adviser pages (PDS, underwriting guides) rank for consumer queries and convert badly.
  3. Comparison sites own the results page. Canstar, Finder and Money.com.au rank above insurers for nearly every generic query.
  4. A trust deficit after the Hayne Royal Commission. Life insurance in Australia carries a reputational burden. Content without visible claims data or expert authorship struggles on these “your money or your life” queries.

Strategy: split by role, unite by entity

Give each brand a clear role in search: Zurich as the insurer and adviser channel, OnePath for existing policyholders and ANZ-channel products. Then win consumer research queries with a trust-led content hub that routes people to an adviser.

What we did

Phase 1 (months 0 to 3): de-cannibalization

  • Map every keyword where both domains rank in the top 50.
  • Assign each cluster to one owner domain. The other domain gets canonical tags, consolidation or noindex, depending on regulatory needs (PDS documents must stay reachable).
  • Cross-domain entity markup: Organization with parentOrganization (Zurich Insurance Group) and subOrganization linking both brands.
  • A clean /advisers/ section: noindex on purely technical underwriting content, and a dedicated XML sitemap for adviser pages.

Phase 2 (months 3 to 6): consumer research hub on zurich.com.au

  • Clusters for income protection, TPD, trauma, life cover and cover inside super. Each gets a pillar page, 8 to 15 supporting articles and an FAQ with FAQPage markup.
  • Tools: a “how much cover do I need” calculator and an income protection premium explainer (age, occupation, waiting period).
  • Expertise: every article signed by a qualified author (actuary, claims manager, or financial adviser with an AFSL reference), reviewed, dated and sourced (APRA, ASIC Moneysmart).

Phase 3 (months 6 to 12): claims transparency and adviser routing

  • A “claims in numbers” page built on APRA’s life insurance claims and disputes statistics: acceptance rates and processing times by product, compared with the industry. A link magnet and a trust signal.
  • “Find an adviser” pages for Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth and Adelaide, with LocalBusiness schema for partner advice practices.
  • Real, anonymized claims stories: one per product, approved by compliance.

Objectives at 12 months

The targets set for the first year, with the assumption behind each.

KPI Target Assumption
Keywords where both domains compete -80% Cluster ownership mapping
Top-3 positions, consumer research cluster +50 to +80 keywords A hub of 60 to 80 pages
Calculator completions +100% Calculators promoted in the hub
Adviser referral leads from organic search +30% City pages and routing calls to action
Referring domains +80 Claims data asset

Compliance

ASIC general advice warning on every page, PDS and Target Market Determination (ASIC RG 274) linked from every product page, and no personal advice in the calculators (wording reviewed by legal). Rules checked on 20 November 2026; this is not legal advice.

Key takeaways

  • Sister domains can cannibalize each other. Give every keyword cluster one owner domain, and handle the other with canonicals, consolidation or noindex.
  • Adviser content and consumer content need separate homes. An underwriting guide that ranks for a consumer question converts badly for both audiences.
  • In life insurance, trust is a ranking input. Named qualified authors and public claims data answer the doubts that searchers bring to the query.

Find out what AI says about your firm

A 30-minute call. I run a few of your prospects’ questions through ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI beforehand, so we start from facts.

Soft white cumulus clouds in a pale blue sky